"The poem you are referring to is not part of the original Statue of Liberty. It was added later.”
-- Stephen Miller, White House spokesman, dismissing "The New Colossus" poem about immigrants

To paraphrase the great Molly Ivins when she wrote about Pat Buchanan's culture war speech at the 1992 Republican National Convention, Stephen Miller's press conference yesterday probably sounded better in the original German.

A quarter century later, they haven't changed, still battling against immigrants.  Not even illegal immigrants, but in this case, legal ones!  Just as a starter, this position he made above trying to rewrite reality about the Statue of Liberty is one taken by many white supremacists and passed along on their websites.  Just a very quick historical note to Mr. Miller and any of his like-minded friends on the point of the words being "added later." So too was "Under God" to the Pledge of Allegiance.  

(The words "Under God" were "added later" to the Pledge of Allegiance nine years after it was adopted.  So, perhaps by the standards of Stephen Miller and pals, God can be ignored in the Pledge of Allegiance, and the Almighty has no meaning to its intent.)

And as long as Mr. Miller and his white supremacist followers -- unless it's the other way around -- are so concerned about the lack of importance for anything "added later," it's worth noting that the Bill of Rights and all 27 Amendments were "added later" to the United States Constitution.  These include the Second Amendment which so many on the far right and white supremacists swear by, and also the First Amendment which allows them to say such stupid things without fear of incarceration or being thrown into the loony bin.  Moreover, as the inveterate Chris Dunn pointed out, 37 of the 50 states were "added later" to the United States  As was Washington, D.C. as capital of the nation.

By the way, so is water when you make Cup o' Soup.  Man, if Stephen Miller thinks the concept of "added later" means you can dismiss its importance, I'd like to see him try eating that dry mixture on its own.  Maybe in white supremacist world, but not in any delicious culinary universe I know.

Of course, given that the Statue of Liberty was a gift from France, its "intent" is not from the Founding Fathers or the U.S. government in the first place, but rather...France.  When the words of Emma Lazarus were added to the Statue, that in and of itself is a specific act and absolutely clear intent of the government.  Besides, why do Miller and his merry band of white supremacists think it was put on the water's edge to greet incoming ships in the first place?  If it wasn't to welcome immigrants, they could have just put it in Nebraska, which needs a tourist attraction a whole lot more than New York.

And as long as we're dealing with history, reality and facts, the poem "The New Colossus" was written as a donation of artworks at an auction raising funds that would allow for constructing the pedestal under the Statue of Liberty -- three years before the the Statute itself was dedicated.  So, in fact, it is part of the history of the Statue of Liberty pedestal on which it is engraved, before the pedestal even existed!!

Alas, all of this is really pretty much for naught.  For all the Sturm und Drang from the White House and the belligerent Stephen Miller yesterday on this anti-immigrant bill, reporter Sam Stein of the Huffington Post commented on The Last Word with Lawrence O'Donnell that the proposal has NO chance of passage.  And every other panelist agreed.  But at least the administration got its dog whistle out to the base, and its white supremacist wing.  However many dwindling dogs there are.

But still, just as a reminder --

Not like the brazen giant of Greek fame,
With conquering limbs astride from land to land;
Here at our sea-washed, sunset gates shall stand
A mighty woman with a torch, whose flame
Is the imprisoned lightning, and her name
Mother of Exiles. From her beacon-hand
Glows world-wide welcome; her mild eyes command
The air-bridged harbor that twin cities frame.

"Keep, ancient lands, your storied pomp!" cries she
With silent lips. "Give me your tired, your poor,
Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,
The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.
Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me,
I lift my lamp beside the golden door!"

Heading back On the Road with Charles Kuralt, this is a much more wistful piece than usual, as he looks at Fort Motte, South Carolina, one of the many small towns in the South disappearing as a way of life is gone, and the once-sleepy cities grow.

This is too bizarre and hilarious. Now Golf Digest is uncovering Trump stories.

On Trump's golf course in Virginia, there his a memorial, signed by Trump himself, honoring the dead soldiers in a Civil War battle so bloody apparently that it's called "The River of Blood." Unfortunately, there's one big problem -- the battle NEVER TOOK PLACE!

(The "funniest" part of the article is when a reporter asked Trump about it, and the best he could come up with as a response was, "How would they know that?  Were they there?"  No, but they're scholars and study and do actual research from records of accounts of military actions from the army and from people who were -- in fact, really -- there.)

And so now we can add one more to our honor roll of moments of silence in memory and the fallen in non-existent massacres and faux-battles of today and throughout history --

Remember Bowling Green.

Remember Atlanta.

Remember Sweden.

Remember The River of Blood.

And in the end, once again, we find the real source and admirer of creating fake news.  It's a third-graders gambit: if you don't know the answer on your test, make it up and hope the teacher won't notice.  And suddenly, Trump not knowing that Frederick Douglass died 120 years ago, that China and Korea have a complicated history going back 1,500 years, and that Andrew Jackson died 16 years before he could have solved the Civil War becomes ever more clear.  And gives fodder to those planning to sue Trump University for fraud.

You can read the article about it here.

"[Hitler] was not using gas on his own people."
-- Press Secretary Sean Spicer 

Happy Passover from the Trump administration.

I swear this is true.  I swear he said that.  Actually it's worse than that -- he was asked to clarify his initial ghastly statement and this was his "do over"!!  Really.  His initial statement had been, "You know, you had someone as despicable as Hitler who didn’t even sink to using chemical weapons,”

He was attempting to shame Russia into supporting the Assad regime, but it came out oh-so wrong.  That's when he was given his mulligan and a second chance to explain better what he meant.  Apparently in TrumpLand, where tone deafness, anti-Semitism and ignorance seems to be the norm, cluelessness covers a wide swath.  His clarification was worse than the first try.

But it gets even worse, as near-impossible as that would seem.  

That's because he followed up this comment that Hitler "was not using gas on his own people" by adding that instead "he brought them into the Holocaust centers.”

Mr. Spicer makes the facilities sound oh-so refreshing, like a Club Med spa.  One wonders why the people even had to be "brought" there at all, but didn't come rushing in on their own to sign up for a membership.  Though I'd hate to see the brochures.  And just to clarify, the proper translation from the original German is "gas chambers."

One also wonders if Sean Spicer meant that Hitler "brought them" much the same as United Airlines brought their reluctant, struggling, screaming passenger off the plane back to the terminal.

Let's be clear:  The ghastly Assad chemical attack which brought the Trump attack killed 70 people.  (The earlier chemical attack by Assad four years earlier killed 1,700, though Trump's relentless response to that was we should not get involved.)  Adolf Hitler rounded up six million Jews into concentration camps and killed them in gas chambers, while putting together a massive military offensive in order to subjugate Europe and ultimately rule the world.

Assad is gruesome and hideously bad.  He doesn't come close to Adolf Hitler.  And the pathetic, ignorant, shameful, tone-deaf, clueless attempt to make a comparison speaks loudly and emphatically to what exists in the White House.

Sean Spicer tried three times to make a clarification.  The thing is, there is no further clarification due.  The only proper response at this point is -- "Oops.  I screwed up.  Oops.  Comparing anyone to Adolf Hitler is idiotic.  Assad is a war criminal and despicable.  But it was foolish to drag Adolf Hitler into this.  I'm sorry.  Oops."

The only good thing to come from this is the knowledge that Melissa McCarthy will be hosting Saturday Night Live in only one month, on May 13.  Which will be broadcast live in prime time.

For a variety of reasons, I've recently been discussing with several people the famous "Vast Wasteland" speech by then-FCC Chariman Newton Minow, who had been appointed by President John Kennedy and who also was -- and remains -- father to my friend, the oft-mentioned here Nell Minow.

It occured to me that although people remarkably still know of the speech and its memborable line after over half a century, few people have actually heard any of it.  So, I figured that that would be A Good Thing and tracked down three minutes of it, including the famous passage.

So, here than from ​May 9, 1961 in an address to the National Association of Broadcasters in Washington, D.C., is a bit of Newton Minow. --

Also, I thought it would be interesting to hear some thoughts from Minow about the speech from a perspective of many decades.  He always has said that, to him, the point of the speech was not the "Vast Wasteland" line, but rather than of television broadcasting in the public interest.  So, here's another four minutes from the good fellow about it all --

And so, we've come to the end.  The theater was dark on the holiday, but we're back with the final episode of the Second Elisberg Industry Film Festival presentation of Fiorello!.  Think of it as the Encore.  I figured that a good way to go out would be with a few off-beat but very appropriate videos.  Bear with me, there are a few treats here, especially for your history buffs..  Hey, you've made it this far -- stick around to the finish.

We'll start off with a song that I didn't post during the main part of the Film Festival, that's because there was no in-production performance video of it, a number called "The Bum Won."  And there isn't such video still, but this here includes a lot of photos from the show.  The song comes after party boss Ben Marino and his political cronies have agreed to let Fiorello LaGuardia run for Congress as a sacrificial lamb against the criminal Tammany Hall organization, with no chance of winning -- and yet to their utter shock the next morning when the results are in, he gets elected.  This is one of my favorite songs in the show for the reason that I love songs with counterpoint...and this is counterpoint on steroids, with musical themes overlapping on musical themes overlappoing on even more themes.  So, here from the original Broadway album is Howard Da Silva and the cast.
​

Next, we have a featurette done for the 2013 Encores! concert-production of Fiorello!  There's no music in the video, just largely actors and others talking about their roles and the show.  But it's noteworthy because it includes the only surviving member of the creative team, lyricist Sheldon Harnick, talking about the show, in particular writing the new number, the reprise of "The Name's LaGuardia."
​

And finally, two unlikely videos that have absolutely nothing directly to do with the production of musical, but everything to do with the musical.  For the past two weeks, we've posting videos about a musical on Fiorello H. LaGuardia, who was mayor of New York CIty for 12 years.  Well, here is newsreel footage of LaGuardia himself.

In this first video, it touches on one of the most remembered and beloved parts of his legacy -- something touched on in the musical at the very beginning of the show, which is in essence a flashback.  During his term in office, there was a big newspaper strike in the city.  And the news aside, one of the consternations it caused was that little children couldn't get their daily comic strips.  So, Mayor LaGuardia would go on the air...and read the comics he was able to get access to.  Here he is reading from "Dick Tracy" in 1945 -- and one of the fun things, which again they touch on in the musical, is how not only does he read the comics, but every once in a while tosses in little political commentaries that relate to them.
​

​
And at least, we come to newsreel footage of Fiorello LaGuardia doing what is, in essence, the foundation that pushed his career forward -- going on the air in 1933 and angrily (and bluntly) railing against the criminal activities of the Tammany Hall organization, still then impacting the city.  It's the best way, I suppose, of finishing things here.  After all, the name's LaGuardia.

I just read this excellent and ghastly Politco article here by Michael Kruse, "He Brutalized for You."  It tells of how Roy Cohn became the mentor of Donald Trump.

Well, that now explains a lot.  

As the article puts it, yes, that Roy Cohn.  The vicious, odious lawyer who was henchman for Sen. Joseph McCarthy (R-WI), and who mercilessly ruined lives, many if not most quite innocent; had mob ties; was disbarred in 1986 for “'fraud, deceit and misrepresentation'— for lying on a bar application, for taking a client’s money, for altering the will of an incapacitated man, among other things;" who journalist Ken Auletta called, “One of the most reptilian characters I’ve ever met;” who was a "Jewish anti-Semite and homosexual homophone'" and had a philosophy best-described as "Say anything. Win at all costs."  Who Trump would often tell people he was negotiating with that they could either talk to him or -- as the ultimate threat to be avoided at all costs-- they could deal with Roy Cohn.

That Roy Cohn.

In 1980, Cohn told the New York Times that he was  “not only Donald’s lawyer, but also one of his close friends.”  An article in Vanity Fair said that they spoke to one another “15 to 20 times a day.”  

When Cohn's connections to the mob became news, though, and Trump had to answer questions from New Jersey’s Division of Gaming Enforcement and Casino Control Commission, author Kruse writes that "Trump distanced himself from a man he once had called 'a genius,' his attorney whose name, face and reputation he would brandish as a weapon."

Similarly, if not more cold-heartedly, when Trump learned that Cohn had AIDS, he began cutting all ties with the lawyer and began moving his business to other attorneys.

That Roy Cohn.  Donald Trump's mentor.  Say anything.  Win at all costs.  It explains SO much.  

Is it fair to paint someone like Donald Trump because of his connection to a person who had ties to someone else?  No, not necessarily.  But that "not necessary" is an important qualifier.  Because when that connection employs many of the very tactics he used previously and acts as a bridge between parties to become a mentor then, yes, it not only is fair but right and proper.  And in this case, necessary.

Check out the full article here .