When the Chips are Down
Updated: 4 days ago
I don't have all that much to add to the story of Nvidia, AI chips, Jensen Huang, Chinese spies, Trump and his administration. Not because everything has been said, but rather because it's so hugely complex and massively convoluted that the depths of it go to so many intricate places that I don't even begin to understand.
But some things do stand out, simply on the surface.
I first read about this story over a week ago and posted a comment about it on social media. And then waited for the deluge to start as national media followed up on what was clearly a immense story dealing with national security. But then crickets. It wasn't for more then a week before it was picked up again. At which point, man, did the dam ever finally break, and the deluge began pouring through. Because it was clearly an immense story dealing with national security. And, it turns out, corruption.
Immense, at almost Brobdingnagian levels, because, among so many other things, Jensen Huang, who founded Nvidia and was its CEO, was so monolithically powerful that the company (which owns 80 other companies) had no succession plans. This is just monumentally incompressible and fiscally irresponsible, most especially for a publicly-traded company. Not because they didn't anticipate a scandal, but because anything could happen to its singular corporate leader -- he could get ill and pass away. He could get hit by a bus. He could decide to retire with no warning. Or...the board of directors could have noticed that a year ago Mr. Huang hired the leading crisis management firm in the country! And so (over the subsequent 12 months ) the board might have figured out that perhaps something could be amiss and maybe it would be a good idea to have a succession plan.
Also -- the FBI has a standard policy that when someone they suspect might be a foreign spy makes significant contact with a U.S. citizen, the FBI will send agents to meet with the American and brief him or her about their suspicions, what they call "a duty to warn." But the FBI, under Trump crackerjack appointee Kash Patel, broke precedent and its duty and did not do that and never reached out to Jensen Huang to warn him.
Also -- related to this, my favorite statement in the story has been Mr. Huang commenting that he never suspected the woman he was having an affair with might have been a Chinese spy. Jim Hines, who will be the new chair of the House Intelligence Committee when Democrats take control, expressed my reaction far better (and funnier) than I did. , "One of the core features of being a spy," he said, "is not letting others know that you're a spy." My friend, the oft-mentioned here Nell Minow has had a similar comment whenever asked about the situation. (It's natural that Nell would be asked, since she's a world expert on corporate governance.) Nell said that her response has been, "Espionage is not on the honor system." She also offered an even more basic reminder, noting the famous line from the opening of the TV series, Mission: Impossible -- "If you, or any member of your IM Team is caught or killed, the secretary will disavow any knowledge of your actions." Also -- related to this, as well, is what many analysts have said. Stephanie Ruhle, though, put it best on her MS NOW show yesterday morning: If you're the head of one of the world's most important companies involved with international security, you likely assume, or should, that everyone you come in contact with might be after you for something. If you go to Starbucks and get a latte, you might even think about having someone taste it first. And if a beautiful woman cozies up to you, it might not be because of your money or cool leather jacket. And so, how Jensen Wong could be so oblivious to the mere possibility that this woman, who was head of a Chinese firm, Megaspeed, (that was actually non-existent) might just possibly be a spy is almost corporate malfeasance.
Also -- related to that, putting aside that Huang now turns out to have had two affairs (once which was with a customer, the other with a subordinate, both of which are reasons that any other CEO would be fired), the fact that the Nvidia board of directors sat on its hands is likely corporate malfeasance, too, because it not only put the company at risk, and put international security at risk, but on its most foundational level, it opened the company to massive lawsuits from stockholders, not only for the board's irresponsibility, but because of how much money their inaction has been lost to investors. From the company's stock price high of just five weeks ago, the valuation has dropped 30% -- for a loss of $1.7 trillion. So far.
Also -- we haven't even gotten to Trump and his cabinet. So, to start with is that Trump was not only briefed on this scandal, but briefed twice. And he not only ignored it and did nothing, but brought Huang with him on trips to China, accepted the sale of AI chips to China -- despite repeatedly insisting that the U.S. had to "win the AI war" against our only adversary, China -- and has continued praising Huang. Also -- Trump's Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick was a major force behind the sale of AI chips to China. Despite Trump insisting that the U.S. had to "win the AI war" against our only adversary, China. When Megaspeed was being investigated during the Biden Administration, it was Lutnick who shut down the investigation when he took over. And even when the Trump administration wanted to put Megaspeed on the sanctions list, it was Lutnick who got that blocked. Also -- Trump's Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent oversees the spending of money by the U.S. government and, without doing any due diligence on this non-existent company run by the woman Jensen Huang was selling AI chips to, clearly let all this pass. Despite (say it all together now ) Trump insisting that the U.S. had to "win the AI war" against our only adversary, China.
Also -- a reminder, as noted above, that FBI Director Patel broke protocol and inexplicably didn't have agents contact Jensen Huang that he might be having an affair with a Chinese spy.
Also -- although Secretary of State and National Security Advisor Marco Rubio did specifically warn Trump about intelligence concerns about Jensen Huang having an affair with a suspected Chinese spy and gets points for that...after warning Trump, Rubio saw his boss was not only doing nothing but was still keeping Jensen Huang close to him, and Secretary of State and National Security Advisor seemingly just shrugged, thought "Whatever," and moved on. He didn't set up protective firewalls, didn't push FBI Director Patel to have agents warn Mr. Huang, and didn't take the admittedly-huge step, though one which some government officials might have done about so massive a national security threat (and one of international proportions) by resigning over such a scandal. Which would have brought attention to it, much earlier than now.
Also -- putting aside the national security threat (which is a mountain range to put aside), the issue is also about massive corruption, which American voters said was the top concern in the Mid-Terms. It starts with Nvidia (under Huang's leadership) donating $25 million to Trump's ballroom and also donating $1 million to Trump's 2025 inaugural fund and then goes through Trump investing millions of his own dollars into Nvidia stock.
Also, also, also, also... It's a story of deluged with also's. And this is just on the surface and from me not knowing or understanding the labyrinthine, deep technological, financial and national security issues.
But...but Hunter Biden's laptop!
But...but President Obama wore a tan suit!
Add this to the list of things that Democrats will hold investigations over when the take control of Congress in January. It is not going away. Nor should it. This is a scandal that's esoteric and filled with minutiae on the one hand, and easy to understand and become seriously angry about on the other. When the scandal broke, Jensen Huang was being described as possibly "Too big to be fired." He wasn't just the founder and in charge of Nvidia -- which, before the scandals, was the most valuable company in the world, with a $5.8 trillion valuation -- but was the sole overseer of the 80 companies Nvidia owned, had no successor, and was in charge of the world leader in a technology so critical that it's been described as potentially capable of destroying mankind. How big is the scandal? It's so massive that, though he was seen as "Too big to be fired," he resigned. But this isn't about Jensen Huang and Nvidia (well, entirely...), it's about Trump who has long enabled and continued to enable Huang and about the MAGOP who enabled Trump. And it's also about other mega-billionaires with overpowering and intricate government contracts who might be considered too big to be fired. Just as Jensen Huang likely once believed, before he resigned.
Comments